The current dating landscape is bleak at best, and no one knows it better than Mackenzie, a disillusioned 25-year-old law student whose love life consists of non-committal hookups and situations from hell. When she has a "real-life date-love" with Finn, a handsome and charming journalist, she begins to believe that true love really does exist. However, when the honeymoon phase wears off and cracks begin to appear, Mackenzie is forced to come to terms with whether or not she is to blame, or if her love is actually too good to be true.